Mystery Short Sleeve Tees

A little mystery makes it more fun. Choose your theme, style, and size, and we’ll take care of the rest! Your Mystery Tee will feature a graphic handpicked by Afton and pressed just for you. For this drop, choose between: 🍂 Fall — cozy autumn vibes, pumpkins, coffee, leaves & everything we love about fall. 🎃 Halloween — spooky, witchy, creepy, cute & Halloween-inspired designs. 🦃 Thanksgiving — thankful hearts, turkey day, festive fall designs & a little holiday humor. Then choose your tee style: Classic A soft, lightweight everyday tee, such as Bella+Canvas or a similar style. Signature A heavier, lived-in tee with that relaxed feel you love, such as Comfort Colors or a similar style. The design and shirt color are part of the surprise—you choose the theme and we choose the rest! Because each Mystery Tee is made especially for you, specific designs and colors cannot be requested. Brands may vary based on availability, but we’ll always choose a comparable style and quality. Processing time: 2–3 business days. Please note: Mystery apparel is made to order and is final sale.