Choose Your Taffy

Your favorites, every month. You already know what you love. Now get it delivered to your door every month — no surprises, no guessing, just your favorite taffy flavors, on repeat. How it works: Choose your 3 favorite flavors from our 22 top fan-favorites Your box ships every month with exactly what you picked Want to switch things up? Just email hello@taffy2you.com with the subject line CHANGE MY FLAVOR by the 15th of the month and we'll update your next box Choose your subscription: 3 Bags — You Choose All 3 ($29/month): Pick every flavor. Your box, your way. 3 Bags + Fan Favorites Bag ($35/month): Your 3 choice bags plus one bag of our most-loved fan-favorite flavors — a great way to find your next favorite. Each bag is 5.3 oz of fresh, real-flavor taffy — made the way it's supposed to taste. 100% Freshness Guaranteed.