Pick Your Mix Taffy

Individual Sour Taffy Flavors Now Available!* Bring home the magic of our seaside kitchens with our Pick Your Mix Taffy, now online by popular demand! Just like in our shop, you get to handpick your own flavor adventure. Choose up to three irresistible flavors per pound! Build your dream mix with juicy Watermelon, tangy Blue Raspberry, creamy Vanilla, or the melt-in-your-mouth sweetness of Strawberry Banana and more. It’s the next best thing to standing in front of our colorful taffy buffet, surrounded by the delicious aroma of over 30+ flavors of fresh taffy. Whether you’re reliving your favorite beach memories or discovering our taffy for the first time, your made-for-you mix promises a treat you won’t forget. With every juicy, chewy bite, you’ll savor the care, craftsmanship, and seaside charm that have made Forbes Candies a coastal tradition for generations. Disclaimer: We cannot guarantee each flavor will have exactly equal amounts of taffy.